Everyone who’s tried it before knows just how complicated finding the best hydrating eye cream can be, especially since they all differ in formulas, textures and ingredient lists. Some are retinol-based, while others come with an intensive AHA complex. Experts, on the other hand, warn that antioxidants are just as equally important. If to that you add moisturizers, caffeine, collagen, and SPF, the options are truly perplexing.
To make your search a bit easier, we’ve compared a couple of the best ranked. Designed by the leading industry brands, these 5 solutions were tested and reviewed by community users and dermatologists alike, so that you can be sure that they deliver what was promised. None of them is harmful for your skin, but their effectiveness may vary in compliance to your specific skin type.
Olay Eyes: Eye Lifting Serum
Straight from the pioneer of inexpensive anti-age care, the Olay Eyes Eye Lifting Cream comes with an impressive formula that feels velvety on your skin and leaves a wonderful glow. For around $30, you’ll get a powerful anti-wrinkle treatment that simultaneously nourishes your under-eye area and makes it as smooth as it was ten or twenty years ago.
Though concocted with around twenty active compounds, this top rated eye cream has a couple of ingredients that deserve to be individually mentioned. Glycerine, for instance, is one of the most powerful solutions for a healthy, natural-looking complexion. As an emollient, this compound makes the skin softer by keeping it hydrated. Niacinamide, on the other hand, is a fusion of Vitamin B3 and nicotinic acid, both of which boost immunity, improve skin barriers and reduce visible signs of aging. Antioxidants and peptides come together to protect your skin from external damages and maintain its natural balance.
Though packed with vitamins, the formula is lightweight and quick to absorb. Since enriched with mineral pigments as well, the Olay’s serum is adored for its luminous effect that minimizes dark circles immediately after application. As such, it is currently the best firming eye cream with a makeup effect on the market, but it has one tiny imperfection.
Brilliant for normal and oily skin, the fragrance-free formula soothes sensitive types too. It is, however, a bit short on moisturizers, which means that those with an atypically dry complexion won’t find it as effective. Apart from this shortcoming, Olay’s Eye Lifting Serum is worthy of all accolades.
Kate Somerville: Retinol Firming Eye Cream
When it comes to the moisture that Olay’s concoction sadly lacks, Kate Somerville’s Retinol Firming Eye Cream is without question the best hydrating eye cream you can find. Coming second with a whooping price of $85, the retinol-packed formula is a miracle worker for all traces of natural or UV-induced aging, from subtle fine lines to deep wrinkles.
It’s loaded with skin-replenishing glycerine as well, but its star ingredient is none other than retinol. Often described as the fountain of youth, this compound is an unparalleled fighter against collagen breakdown, which makes it an anti-aging favourite of consumers and experts alike. Since penetrating deep through your skin, retinoids work on an intercellular level, thus preventing acne, treating conditions like psoriasis and lightening brown spots. It’s an all-in-one solution for tired, blemished and dull skin that usually comes with aging.
Unfortunately, it’s not something that can be prevented, but that makes high-quality skincare that much more important. Speaking of which, Kate Somerville’s pricey eye cream is a winner in a couple of other categories as well – the silky texture feels wonderfully refreshing when applied, thus earning the flattering title of the best cream for eye bags. You’ll be delighted to hear that you can wear it under your makeup too.
What’s also praise-worthy about this hydrating, firming and brightening solution is its packaging. Being opaque, the tube keeps all the active ingredients stable, while the metal applicator contributes to both ease of use and the refreshing effect. It’s suitable for all skin types.
Dermalogica: Total Eye Care SPF 15
When one product makes the best hydrating eye cream, the best eye cream for dark circles and the best cream for eye bags at the same time, then it truly deserves to be called Total Eye Care. Developed by Dermalogica, this comprehensive treatment comes with an interesting set of ingredients, but what really makes it special is its non-chemical SPF, so rarely found in eye creams.
For ladies who wear make-up on a daily basis, having a non-greasy base that simultaneously protects from harmful UV rays is of critical importance. Otherwise, they would have to apply sunscreen over the eye cream and cover it again with a concealer, which can form a thick, weighty layer and feel quite overwhelming. Though not higher than 15, Dermalogica’s titanium oxide-based SPF is all the protection your sensitive under-eye area needs.
As for the rest of the ingredients, the Total Eye Care formula doesn’t let down in the skin repair department neither. The AHA complex (alpha hydroxyl acids) serves as a natural exfoliant, minimizes discolorations and smoothens the skin, which pretty much covers dark circles. Still, the mix includes optical light diffusers as well, thus making them even less visible. In addition to mica, talc and iron oxides, the ingredient list reveals moisturizing emollients too, complemented with a wide range of plant extracts that successfully eliminate puffiness. It does lack some antioxidants, though, but that certainly doesn’t diminish the cream’s effectiveness.
Total Eye Care works best with normal, oily and dry types. The lightweight formula is made fragrance-free, which qualifies it for the best eye cream for the sensitive skin category as well. Powerful and versatile, it justifies its $50 price tag.
Aveda: Botanical Kinetics Energizing Eye Cream
Although the first under-eye care product to be included to the Aveda’s Botanical Kinetics line, this energizing solution is definitely the best hydrating eye cream available on the market. That said, the formula at hand slightly falls behind the rest of the category leaders – while incredibly soothing on dry skin, it doesn’t reduce fine lines and dark circles as well as other products on this list.
According to the best eye cream reviews, its texture is exceptionally creamy, rich and nourishing. It contains more moisturizing emollients than its contenders, but it still absorbs easily and stays refreshingly moist hours after application. Since it’s fragrance-free and gentle, the cream won’t mess up your makeup or make your skin oilier than it should.
All this is due to its cleverly chosen and carefully merged ingredients. While emollients contribute to moisture, the plant-based antioxidants repair the skin from within. Together with fatty acids, added for collagen production, these beneficial compounds have a strong anti-inflammatory effect, thus preventing puffiness as well.
When the package says that Aveda’s solution is 98% naturally derived, try not to frown – water, plants and non-petroleum are indeed as natural as an eye cream can get without compromising its effectiveness. Suitable for all skin types, this powerful eye puffiness cream is especially recommended for those with a dry complexion.
Olay: Regenerist Anti-Aging Eye Roller
Olay’s already been honoured with a spot on our best hydrating eye creams list, but we cannot leave out the brand’s most famous solution. The roller concept may not be revolutionary, yet ladies have gone mad over the Regenerist package. And why wouldn’t they? Olay has managed to deliver the product that’s both loaded with great anti-aging and anti-inflammatory ingredients and compacted into a state-of-the-art applicator.
Formula-wise, this eye cream doesn’t surprise nor does it disappoint. Everything needed for effective under-eye care is here, which makes it a great representative of eye creams for dark circles, puffiness, and wrinkles alike. While glycerin provides sufficient amounts of moisture, caffeine dehydrates the area just enough to keep it smooth and de-puffed. The mix is loaded with antioxidants as well, thus guaranteeing the infallible treatment for all unsightly eye area problems.
It’s how the formula is applied that makes all the difference. The pen is completed with a rollerball tip – because it’s made of metal, the applicator enhances the cooling effect, additionally soothes the skin and reduces eye bags, regardless of how stubborn they are. As long-term users claim, the pen releases just the right amount of cream with a single click.
Though somewhat old, the Regenerist Anti-Aging Eye Roller is considered a timeless piece of under- eye care gear. With fast and visible results and convenient packaging, it falls under those beauty products that we’ll hardly ever get enough of.
Other Honourable Mentions
Many reviewers have found their best hydrating eye cream in Ole Henriksen Ultimate Lift Eye Gel, La Mer The Eye Concentrate, Kiehl’s Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado and Shiseido Future Solution LX Eye and Lip Contour Regenerating Cream. With an average member rating of 9.6, the SkinCeuticals Eye Balm holds the number one position on TotalBeauty.com, but experts have some concerns about its combination of jar packaging and light-sensitive ingredients.
Whichever you choose, remember that the best hydrating eye cream doesn’t necessarily have to be the one that has received the loudest applause. As long as it feels great on your skin, keeps your sensitive under-eye area ideally hydrated, ameliorates your specific problem and doesn’t cause any irritations, any of these top-rated solutions can be your magic formula.